____Group No.

(I'll use this form to evaluate the OFS paper.)

OFS  Paper Evaluation Form. Agreement with each statement?
1 = Strongly disagree 2 = Disagree  3 = Neither agree nor disagree  4 = Agree  5 = Strongly agree

       Depth of Analysis

      _____1. The paper demonstrates a thorough understanding of reframing.

      _____2.   The paper  presented adequate, coherent, and logical argument in support of its frame analysis.

      _____3.    The paper supported its diagnosis with documentation from the text.                                     

      _____4.   The paper  presented an overall, in-depth and valid frame analysis of the organization.              

      _____5.The suggestions for improvement were based on a complete and valid frame analysis

      _____6.  The group understands metaphor and used one skillfully.
 

      Practicality of Recommendations

      _____7. The group's recommendations could be executed successfully in "real world" scenarios.
 

     ______8 The recommendations make sense and derived from the frame analysis.
 

Organization and Presentation On Writing

    _____9. Logic, reasoning, coherence, and organization.



    _____10. Syntax, sentence structure, word choice and grammar.



    _____11. Clarity, thoroughness, and creativity.

 

   _____12. Overall, the writing quality was among the best one should expect from MBA students at Bloch